[ratelimits] can't trigger rate-limit

Irwin Tillman irwin at princeton.edu
Wed Jan 2 16:13:07 UTC 2013


> From: Vernon Schryver <vjs at rhyolite.com>

>I belatedly remembered the tests in bin/tests/system.  The instructions
>in bin/tests/system/README should lead to configuring loopback interfaces
>on net-10 and then run the rrl test:
>...

OK, here it is:

# cd /var/local/src/bind-9.9.2-P1+rl-20121231/bin/tests/system/
# ./ifconfig.sh up
# ifconfig -a
lo0: flags=2001000849<UP,LOOPBACK,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4,VIRTUAL> mtu 8232 index 1
        inet 127.0.0.1 netmask ff000000 
lo0:1: flags=2001000849<UP,LOOPBACK,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4,VIRTUAL> mtu 8232 index 1
        inet 10.53.0.1 netmask ff000000 
lo0:2: flags=2001000849<UP,LOOPBACK,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4,VIRTUAL> mtu 8232 index 1
        inet 10.53.0.2 netmask ff000000 
lo0:3: flags=2001000849<UP,LOOPBACK,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4,VIRTUAL> mtu 8232 index 1
        inet 10.53.0.3 netmask ff000000 
lo0:4: flags=2001000849<UP,LOOPBACK,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4,VIRTUAL> mtu 8232 index 1
        inet 10.53.0.4 netmask ff000000 
lo0:5: flags=2001000849<UP,LOOPBACK,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4,VIRTUAL> mtu 8232 index 1
        inet 10.53.0.5 netmask ff000000 
lo0:6: flags=2001000849<UP,LOOPBACK,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4,VIRTUAL> mtu 8232 index 1
        inet 10.53.0.6 netmask ff000000 
lo0:7: flags=2001000849<UP,LOOPBACK,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4,VIRTUAL> mtu 8232 index 1
        inet 10.53.0.7 netmask ff000000 
bge0: flags=1000843<UP,BROADCAST,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4> mtu 1500 index 2
       ...

(Tests want to write here; temporarily allow non-root user to write here.)
# cd /var/local/src/bind-9.9.2-P1+rl-20121231/bin/tests/system
# chgrp systems . rrl/
# chmod g+w .
# chmod -R g+w rrl/


% cd /var/local/src/bind-9.9.2-P1+rl-20121231/bin/tests/system/
% sh run.sh rrl
S:rrl:Wed Jan  2 10:43:28 EST 2013
T:rrl:1:A
A:System test rrl
I:24 instead of 3 192.168.2.1 responses for a1.tld2
I:0 instead of 7 truncation responses for a1.tld2
I:0 instead of 14 dropped responses for a1.tld2
I:30 instead of 2 192.168.2.2 responses for x*.a2.tld2
I:0 instead of 9 truncation responses for x*.a2.tld2
I:0 instead of 19 dropped responses for x*.a2.tld2
I:21 instead of 3 192.168.3.3 responses for y*.a3.tld3
I:0 instead of 6 truncation responses for y*.a3.tld3
I:0 instead of 12 dropped responses for y*.a3.tld3
I:0 instead of 6 truncation responses for z*.a4.tld2
I:0 instead of 12 dropped responses for z*.a4.tld2
I:20 instead of 2 NXDOMAIN responses for z*.a4.tld2
I:0 instead of 5 truncation responses for a7.tld4
I:0 instead of 13 dropped responses for a7.tld4
I:20 instead of 2 error responses for a7.tld4
I:80 instead of 70 192.168.2.8 responses for a*.a8.tld2
I:0 instead of 3 truncation responses for a*.a8.tld2
I:0 instead of 7 dropped responses for a*.a8.tld2
I:exit status: 1
R:FAIL
E:rrl:Wed Jan  2 10:43:48 EST 2013


% grep ' rrl ' /var/local/src/bind-9.9.2-P1+rl-20121231/bin/tests/system/rrl/ns2/named.run
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.114 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.114 rrl age=16777216  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.166 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.166 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.226 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.226 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.290 rrl age=1  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.290 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.339 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.339 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.359 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.359 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.456 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.456 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.458 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.458 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.507 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.507 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.574 rrl age=0  responses=16777211
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.574 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.638 rrl age=0  responses=16777210
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.638 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.639 rrl age=0  responses=16777209
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.639 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.729 rrl age=0  responses=16777208
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.730 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.737 rrl age=0  responses=16777207
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.737 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.824 rrl age=0  responses=16777206
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.824 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.869 rrl age=0  responses=16777205
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.869 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.889 rrl age=0  responses=16777204
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.889 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.979 rrl age=0  responses=16777203
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.979 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.086 rrl age=1  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.086 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.088 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.088 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.092 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.092 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.152 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.152 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.154 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.154 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.185 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.185 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.255 increase from 2 to 3 RRL entries with 3 bins; average search length 1.0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.255 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.255 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.338 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.338 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.386 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.386 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.427 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.427 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.497 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.497 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.591 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.591 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.609 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.609 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.625 rrl age=0  responses=16777211
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.625 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.693 rrl age=0  responses=16777210
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.693 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.737 rrl age=0  responses=16777209
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.737 rrl age=0  responses=55
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.787 rrl age=0  responses=16777208
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.787 rrl age=0  responses=54
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.860 rrl age=0  responses=16777207
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.860 rrl age=0  responses=53
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.914 rrl age=0  responses=16777206
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.914 rrl age=0  responses=52
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.970 rrl age=0  responses=16777205
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.970 rrl age=0  responses=51
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.988 rrl age=0  responses=16777204
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.988 rrl age=0  responses=50
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.030 rrl age=1  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.030 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.069 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.069 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.147 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.147 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.242 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.242 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.247 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.248 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.343 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.343 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.366 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.366 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.388 rrl age=0  responses=16777211
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.388 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.433 rrl age=0  responses=16777210
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.433 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.488 rrl age=0  responses=16777209
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.488 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.559 rrl age=0  responses=16777208
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.559 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.612 rrl age=0  responses=16777207
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.612 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.693 rrl age=0  responses=16777206
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.693 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.711 rrl age=0  responses=16777205
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.711 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.744 rrl age=0  responses=16777204
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.744 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.156 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.156 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.234 increase from 3 to 5 RRL entries with 3 bins; average search length 1.1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.234 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.234 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.262 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.262 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.388 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.388 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.390 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.390 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.472 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.472 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.537 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.537 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.609 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.609 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.618 rrl age=0  responses=16777211
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.618 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.737 rrl age=0  responses=16777210
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.737 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.737 rrl age=0  responses=16777209
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.738 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.809 rrl age=0  responses=16777208
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.809 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.893 rrl age=0  responses=16777207
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.893 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.955 rrl age=0  responses=16777206
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.955 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.017 rrl age=1  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.017 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.049 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.049 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.056 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.056 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.125 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.125 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.253 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.253 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.297 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.297 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.384 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.384 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.399 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.399 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.401 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.401 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.403 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.403 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.452 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.452 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.562 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.562 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.624 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.624 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.678 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.678 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.723 rrl age=0  responses=16777211
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.723 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.769 rrl age=0  responses=16777210
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.769 rrl age=0  responses=55
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.836 rrl age=0  responses=16777209
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.836 rrl age=0  responses=54
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.854 rrl age=0  responses=16777208
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.854 rrl age=0  responses=53
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.923 rrl age=0  responses=16777207
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.923 rrl age=0  responses=52
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.990 rrl age=0  responses=16777206
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.990 rrl age=0  responses=51
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.055 rrl age=1  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.055 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.096 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.096 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.170 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.170 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.241 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.241 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.326 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.326 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.341 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.341 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.398 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:38.398 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:40.978 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:40.978 rrl age=2  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:40.996 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:40.996 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.056 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.056 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.057 rrl age=1  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.057 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.122 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.122 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.123 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.123 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.186 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.186 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.188 rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.188 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.257 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.257 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.258 rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.259 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.326 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.326 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.328 rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.328 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.417 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.418 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.419 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.419 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.420 rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.420 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.421 rrl age=0  responses=16777212
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.421 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.425 rrl age=0  responses=16777211
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.425 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.427 rrl age=0  responses=16777211
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.427 rrl age=0  responses=55
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.527 rrl age=0  responses=16777210
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.527 rrl age=0  responses=54
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.528 rrl age=0  responses=16777210
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.528 rrl age=0  responses=53
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.601 rrl age=0  responses=16777209
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.601 rrl age=0  responses=52
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.602 rrl age=0  responses=16777209
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.602 rrl age=0  responses=51
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.635 rrl age=0  responses=16777208
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.635 rrl age=0  responses=50
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.637 rrl age=0  responses=16777208
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.637 rrl age=0  responses=49
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.696 rrl age=0  responses=16777207
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.696 rrl age=0  responses=48
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.698 rrl age=0  responses=16777207
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.698 rrl age=0  responses=47
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.699 rrl age=0  responses=16777206
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.699 rrl age=0  responses=46
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.719 rrl age=0  responses=16777206
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.719 rrl age=0  responses=45
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.796 rrl age=0  responses=16777205
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.796 rrl age=0  responses=44
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.798 rrl age=0  responses=16777205
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.798 rrl age=0  responses=43
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.819 rrl age=0  responses=16777204
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.819 rrl age=0  responses=42
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.821 rrl age=0  responses=16777204
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.821 rrl age=0  responses=41
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.853 rrl age=0  responses=16777203
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.853 rrl age=0  responses=40
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.855 rrl age=0  responses=16777203
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.855 rrl age=0  responses=39
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.932 rrl age=0  responses=16777202
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.932 rrl age=0  responses=38
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.934 rrl age=0  responses=16777202
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.934 rrl age=0  responses=37
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.937 rrl age=0  responses=16777201
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.937 rrl age=0  responses=36
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.939 rrl age=0  responses=16777201
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.939 rrl age=0  responses=35
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.978 rrl age=0  responses=16777200
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.978 rrl age=0  responses=34
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.980 rrl age=0  responses=16777200
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.980 rrl age=0  responses=33
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.092 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.093 rrl age=2  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.137 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.137 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.221 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.221 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.224 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.224 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.232 increase from 5 to 8 RRL entries with 3 bins; average search length 1.5
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.232 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.233 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.341 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.341 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.356 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.356 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.358 increase from 8 to 12 RRL entries with 3 bins; average search length 1.6
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.358 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.358 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.439 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.439 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.492 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.493 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.554 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.555 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.612 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.612 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.650 increase from 12 to 18 RRL entries with 3 bins; average search length 1.8
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.650 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.651 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.718 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.718 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.722 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.722 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.783 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.783 rrl age=0  responses=55
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.849 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.849 rrl age=0  responses=54
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.898 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.898 rrl age=0  responses=53
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.940 increase from 18 to 27 RRL entries with 3 bins; average search length 6.0
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.941 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.941 rrl age=0  responses=52
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.075 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.075 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.229 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.229 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.252 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.252 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.252 rrl age=1  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.252 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.342 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.342 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.393 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.393 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.449 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.449 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.451 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.451 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.531 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.531 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.603 increase from 27 to 41 RRL entries with 3 bins; average search length 7.5
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.603 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.603 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.625 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.625 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.670 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.670 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.738 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.738 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.805 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.805 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.810 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.810 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.865 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.865 rrl age=0  responses=55
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.869 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.869 rrl age=0  responses=54
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.956 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.956 rrl age=0  responses=53
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.062 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.062 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.090 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.090 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.107 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.107 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.164 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.164 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.171 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.171 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.239 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.239 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.329 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.329 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.379 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.379 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.420 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.420 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.460 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.460 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.498 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.498 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.579 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.579 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.620 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.620 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.701 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.701 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.703 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.703 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.753 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.753 rrl age=0  responses=55
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.805 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.805 rrl age=0  responses=54
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.862 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.862 rrl age=0  responses=53
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.921 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.921 rrl age=0  responses=52
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.934 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.934 rrl age=0  responses=51
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.001 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.001 rrl age=0  responses=50
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.011 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.011 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.091 rrl age=1  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.091 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.095 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.095 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.225 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.225 rrl age=0  responses=67
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.276 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.276 rrl age=0  responses=66
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.276 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.276 rrl age=0  responses=65
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.377 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.377 rrl age=0  responses=64
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.379 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.379 rrl age=0  responses=63
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.527 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.527 increase from 3 to 41 RRL bins for 41 entries; average search length 11.6
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.527 rrl age=0  responses=62
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.585 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.585 rrl age=0  responses=61
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.678 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.678 rrl age=0  responses=60
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.681 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.681 rrl age=0  responses=59
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.725 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.725 rrl age=0  responses=58
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.833 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.833 rrl age=0  responses=57
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.863 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.863 rrl age=0  responses=56
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.890 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.890 rrl age=0  responses=55
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.979 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.979 rrl age=0  responses=54
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.983 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.983 rrl age=0  responses=53
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.072 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.072 rrl age=1  responses=70
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.075 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.075 rrl age=0  responses=69
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.106 rrl age=16777216  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.106 rrl age=0  responses=68
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.174 rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.174 rrl age=0  responses=67


% grep 'consider limiting response' /var/local/src/bind-9.9.2-P1+rl-20121231/bin/tests/system/rrl/ns2/named.run
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.114 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.166 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:32.226 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.290 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.339 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.359 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.456 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.458 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.507 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.574 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.638 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.639 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.729 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.737 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.824 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.869 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.889 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:33.979 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.086 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.088 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.092 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.152 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.154 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.185 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for a1.tld2 IN A  (0001daf6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.255 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x025.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.338 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x026.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.386 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x028.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.427 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x027.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.497 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x029.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.591 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x030.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.609 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x031.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.624 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x032.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.693 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x033.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.737 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x034.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.787 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x035.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.860 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x036.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.914 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x037.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.970 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x040.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:34.988 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x038.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.030 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x041.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.069 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x039.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.147 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x042.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.241 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x043.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.247 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x044.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.343 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x045.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.366 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x046.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.388 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x048.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.433 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x047.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.488 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x049.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.559 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x050.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.612 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x051.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.693 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x052.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.711 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x054.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:35.744 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for x053.a2.tld2 IN A  (0001daf7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.156 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for y055.a3.tld3 IN A  (0003ab50)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.234 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.262 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.388 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.390 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.472 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.537 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.609 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.618 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.737 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.737 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.809 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.893 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:36.955 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.017 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.049 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.056 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.125 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.253 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.401 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:37.403 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld3 IN A  (0001d6bb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:40.978 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for . IN A  (00000000)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.056 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.122 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.186 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.257 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.326 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.417 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.419 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.425 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.527 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.601 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.635 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.696 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.699 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.796 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.819 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.853 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.932 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.937 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:41.978 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for tld4 IN A  (0001d6bc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.092 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all101.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd86)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.137 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all102.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd87)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.221 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all105.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd8a)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.224 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all107.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd8c)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.232 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all103.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd88)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.341 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all108.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd8d)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.356 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all104.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd89)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.358 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all106.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd8b)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.439 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all109.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd8e)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.492 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all110.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd8e)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.554 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all111.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd8f)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.612 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all112.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd90)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.650 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all113.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd91)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.718 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all115.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd93)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.722 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all114.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd92)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.783 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all116.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd94)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.849 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all117.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd95)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.898 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all118.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd96)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:43.940 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all119.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd97)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.075 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all121.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd98)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.229 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all123.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd9a)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.252 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all122.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd99)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.252 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all120.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd97)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.342 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all124.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd9b)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.393 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all125.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd9c)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.449 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all127.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd9e)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.451 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all126.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd9d)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.531 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all128.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fd9f)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.603 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all129.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda0)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.625 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all130.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda0)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.670 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all131.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda1)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.738 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all132.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda2)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.805 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all135.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda5)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.810 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all134.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda4)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.865 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all133.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda3)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.869 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all136.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:44.956 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all137.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.062 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all138.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda8)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.090 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all140.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda9)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.107 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all139.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fda9)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.164 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all141.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdaa)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.171 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all142.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdab)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.239 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all143.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdac)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.329 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all144.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdad)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.379 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all146.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdaf)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.420 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all145.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdae)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.460 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all147.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb0)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.498 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all148.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb1)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.579 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all149.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb2)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.620 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all152.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb4)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.701 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all151.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb3)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.703 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all150.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb2)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.753 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all153.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb5)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.805 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all155.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.862 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all154.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.921 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all156.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb8)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:45.934 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all157.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdb9)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.001 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all159.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdbb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.011 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all158.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdba)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.091 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all160.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdbb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.095 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all161.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdbc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.224 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all162.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdbd)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.276 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all163.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdbe)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.276 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all164.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdbf)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.377 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all165.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc0)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.379 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all166.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc1)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.527 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all167.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc2)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.585 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all168.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc3)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.678 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all169.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc4)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.680 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all170.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc4)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.725 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all171.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc5)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.833 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all172.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc6)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.863 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all173.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc7)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.890 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all174.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc8)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.979 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all175.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdc9)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:46.983 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all177.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdcb)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.072 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all179.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdcd)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.075 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all176.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdca)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.106 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all178.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdcc)
02-Jan-2013 10:43:47.174 consider limiting response to 10.53.0.0/24 for all180.a8.tld2 IN A  (0095fdcd)


# ./ifconfig.sh down

(Restore permissions changed temporarily.)
# cd /var/local/src/bind-9.9.2-P1+rl-20121231/bin/tests/system
# chgrp bin . rrl/
# chmod g+w .
# chmod -R g+w rrl/


--

>Changing "severity info" to "severity debug 10" should generate noise
>in /tmp/rl-log

OK, here's that:


% cat /tmp/named.conf
options {
   directory        "/tmp";
   pid-file         "pid";
   session-keyfile  "session.key";
   listen-on        port 8053 { 127.0.0.1; };
   rate-limit {
       responses-per-second 5;
   };
};
logging {
    channel rl {
        severity debug 10;
        print-category yes; print-time yes; print-severity yes; file "rl-log";
    };
    category rate-limit { rl; };
};


# rm /tmp/rl-log
# /usr/local/sbin/named -f -c /tmp/named.conf

%  repeat 10 dig @127.0.0.1 +short +tries=1 +time=3  -p 8053 rhyolite.com

# (kill named)


messages:

Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: starting BIND 9.9.2-vjs340.03-P1 -f -c /tmp/named.conf
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: built with '--sysconfdir=/usr/local/etc' 'CC=cc' 'CFLAGS=-L/usr/local/lib -fast' 'LDFLAGS=-R/usr/local/lib'
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: ----------------------------------------------------
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: BIND 9 is maintained by Internet Systems Consortium,
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: Inc. (ISC), a non-profit 501(c)(3) public-benefit 
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: corporation.  Support and training for BIND 9 are 
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: available at https://www.isc.org/support
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: ----------------------------------------------------
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: open: /usr/local/etc/rndc.key: file not found
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: couldn't add command channel 127.0.0.1#953: file not found
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: open: /usr/local/etc/rndc.key: file not found
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: couldn't add command channel ::1#953: file not found
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: all zones loaded
Jan  2 10:58:43 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: running
Jan  2 10:58:53 scramble.Princeton.EDU named[27955]: exiting


% cat /tmp/rl-log
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.448 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.449 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=16777216  responses=5
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.501 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.501 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=4
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.548 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.548 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=3
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.595 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.595 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=2
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.642 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.642 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=1
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.690 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.690 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=0
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.736 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.736 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=16777215
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.783 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.783 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=16777214
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.830 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.830 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=16777213
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.876 rate-limit: debug 3: consider limiting response to 127.0.0.0/24 for rhyolite.com IN A  (38cbb7f2)
02-Jan-2013 10:58:50.876 rate-limit: debug 9: rrl age=0  responses=16777212


--


>] script patch.out
>] patch -p0 < ../bind-rl-9.9.2-P1.patch-20121231
>] exit
>
>What is the provinance of bind-rl-9.9.2-P1.patch-20121231 ?
>The file linked on http://www.redbarn.org/dns/ratelimits
>is http://ss.vix.com/~vixie/rl-9.9.2-P1.patch


bind-rl-9.9.2-P1.patch-20121231 is a copy of http://ss.vix.com/~vixie/rl-9.9.2-P1.patch
I retrieved December 31 2012.  
I saved the file locally with a different name.

% openssl sha1 /usr/local/src/bind-rl-9.9.2-P1.patch-20121231  
SHA1(/usr/local/src/bind-rl-9.9.2-P1.patch-20121231)= bc71f1b59b1885d75400475a9b69eed5201b51fc


>What does `named -v` say?  If you used a true copy of the official
>unofficial patch, it should say something like "BIND 9.9.2-vjs340.03"

% /usr/local/sbin/named -v
BIND 9.9.2-vjs340.03-P1


Thank you for your help.

Irwin Tillman


More information about the ratelimits mailing list